Home / Reviews / Google Pixel 4 review—Overpriced, uncompetitive, and out of touchars_ab.settitle(1589011);

Google Pixel 4 review—Overpriced, uncompetitive, and out of touchars_ab.settitle(1589011);

The Pixel Four arrived in the marketplace as one of the vital leaked, most talked about smartphones of 2019. This yr, Google looks as if it’s actually looking for one thing distinctive to supply, with new options just like the Google-developed “Movement Sense” radar gesture system, face unlock, a 90Hz show, the next-gen Google Assistant, and a brand new astrophotography mode.

On the costs Google is asking, although, the Pixel Four is tough to advocate. The corporate saddled the telephone with an ultra-premium price ticket, however the Pixel Four cannot compete with ultra-premium telephones. The telephone falls down on a whole lot of the fundamentals, like battery life, storage pace, design, and extra. The brand new additions like face unlock and Movement Sense simply do not work properly. It looks as if Google simply minimize too many corners this yr.

The strongest characteristic of the Pixel line—the digital camera—hasn’t actually gotten higher, both. The digital camera sensor is identical as final yr, and the massive new software program characteristic, astrophotography mode, can be out there on older Pixel gadgets and the less expensive Pixel 3a.

The Pixel Four is not unhealthy in a vacuum, however the remainder of Google’s Android competitors will get higher yearly, whereas Google stands nonetheless. This yr, Google turned in a weak, timid replace to its flagship smartphone, and I am undecided who to advocate this to at $800 or $900. Google simply cannot do premium proper. So, when can we have now the Nexus line again?

Desk of Contents

  • Design and construct high quality
  • The Pixel 4’s horrible worth proposition
  • Face unlock—Sluggish, unreliable, and irritating
  • Movement Sense with Undertaking Soli—By no means what was promised
  • The subsequent-gen Google Assistant
  • Digital camera—Just about the identical because the Pixel 3
  • What’s the level of the Pixel line?
  • The Good
  • The Unhealthy
  • The Ugly

Design and construct high quality

We’ll begin with the very best a part of the Pixel 4: the again. The Pixel Four is, as standard, a glass and aluminum sandwich, with a Gorilla Glass 5 entrance, an aluminum body uncovered alongside the perimeters, and a glass again. After we discuss in regards to the rear design of the Pixel 4, be aware that between the three out there colours, there are two completely totally different end choices that significantly have an effect on the texture of the machine.

The black model has a regular shiny glass again that makes use of Gorilla Glass 5, and the black model looks like the same old slippery fingerprint magnet that every one glass telephones are. The white and orange colours use a unique glass panel that is not Gorilla Glass, although, and these get a particular soft-touch therapy. Whereas this soft-touch glass again is perhaps paying homage to the soft-touch again on the Pixel Three final yr, this yr there have been a lot of enhancements.

SPECS AT A GLANCE
Pixel 4Pixel Four XL
SCREEN2280×1080 5.7-inches (440 ppi)

OLED, 19:9 side ratio

3040×1440 6.3-inches (523ppi)

OLED, 19:9 side ratio

OSAndroid 10
CPUEight-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 855

4 Cortex A76-based cores (One 2.84GHz, three 2.41Ghz) and 4 Cortex A55-based cores at 1.78GHz

RAM6GB
GPUAdreno 640
STORAGE64GB or 128GB
NETWORKING802.11b/g/n/ac 2×2, Bluetooth 5.0 + LE, GPS, NFC, eSIM
Bands

(NA mannequin)

GSM: 850, 900, 1800, 1900

UMTS/HSPA: 1, 2, 4, 5, 8
CDMA: BC0, BC1, BC10
LTE: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 19, 20, 25, 26, 28, 29, 30, 38, 39, 40, 41, 46, 48, 66, 71

PORTSUSB Kind-C 3.1 Gen 1
CAMERARear: 12MP predominant digital camera, 16MP telephoto (x2)

Entrance: 8MP digital camera

SIZE147.1×68.8×8.2 mm160.4×75.1×8.2 mm
WEIGHT162g193g
BATTERY2800mAh3700mAh
STARTING PRICE$799$899
OTHER PERKSUSB-PD fast charging, face unlock, IP68 mud and water resistance, Energetic Edge, Pixel Neural Core, Titan M safety module

First, the brand new soft-touch backs can now not be dented by a fingerprint, they usually really feel noticeably extra sturdy than the soft-touch coating on the Pixel 3. Second, whereas the Pixel Three coating tended to soak up and maintain onto fingerprint grease, the Pixel Four hides fingerprints very properly. The soft-touch Pixel Four again appears to be like and feels clear on a regular basis, and I am not compelled to clean it down with cleaning soap and water each 5 minutes like with the Pixel 3.

I might somewhat we simply not make telephones out of glass in any respect, but when we have now to, the soft-touch coating on the white and orange Pixel Four actually is the very best available in the market. The again gives an agreeable quantity of grip that you aren’t getting with common glass. It appears to be like nice, it stays clear, and it appears sturdy. This is likely one of the few components of the Pixel Four that’s totally different and higher than the competitors, and I hope different producers copy the soft-touch implementation right here.

The complete again of the Pixel Four is nice, truly. This yr, Google jumped on the multi-camera bandwagon and added a 16MP telephoto lens. The entire digital camera meeting—which incorporates an LED flash, microphone, and spectral/flicker sensor—now lives in a giant black sq. tucked neatly into the nook of the telephone. It is a comparable resolution to the iPhone 11, however I daresay Google’s digital camera block appears to be like higher. In individual the black inside does a great job of hiding the litter of the digital camera {hardware}, which I feel appears to be like cleaner than the purposefully highlighted lenses of the iPhone 11. Folks like to think about shapes in these digital camera assemblies, so if the iPhone 11 Professional digital camera block appears to be like like a stovetop or fidget spinner, the Pixel Four appears to be like like a shocked robotic or Pikachu face. Due to the black inside, although, the Pixel Four is significantly extra refined about it.

The black digital camera block gives a satisfying distinction to the white or orange backs, and the black ring across the perimeter of the telephone ties all of it collectively pleasantly. The again actually is good-looking. Whereas the perimeters are ultimately aluminum, you will not be touching any naked steel whenever you maintain the Pixel 4. The edges have what Google calls a “matte end hybrid coating,” which simply looks like a tough plastic shell. It would not appear any grippier than anodized aluminum, so I am undecided why Google bothered.

The many sensors in the Pixel 4's top bezel.
Enlarge / The numerous sensors within the Pixel 4’s high bezel.
Ron Amadeo / Google

As standard, the entrance design for the Pixel line appears to be like dated this yr. The Pixel Four has a large bezel solely on the highest of the machine, which provides the telephone a lopsided, top-heavy look. Most telephones have aimed to scale back the bezels as a lot as doable, going for under a minimal digital camera blemish or, generally, no blemish in any respect. However not Google. The Pixel Four design jogs my memory of the Galaxy S8, a telephone that got here out two years in the past, and the stats again that up. The Pixel Four has an 81.3% screen-to-bezel ratio, whereas the Galaxy S8 has a extra environment friendly use of house, with an 83.6% screen-to-bezel ratio.

The highest bezel may appear like one thing from 2017, nevertheless it is being put to make use of, as Google is packing the highest of the telephone with sensors and options. In addition to the traditional 8MP selfie digital camera, earpiece, and ambient gentle/proximity sensor, there’s a complete system for 3D face unlock, which makes use of two IR cameras, an IR dot projector, and an IR flood illuminator. There’s additionally a Google-developed Soli radar sensor, which is used to detect air gestures above the telephone in addition to the person’s presence.

Among the many greatest upgrades within the Pixel Four this yr is the addition of a 90Hz OLED show. Sooner refresh-rate shows are rapidly turning into the brand new pattern in smartphone design, with Razer, Asus, OnePlus, and some different Chinese language manufacturers getting in on the motion. We beloved the 90Hz shows on the OnePlus 7 Professional and 7T, the place the upper refresh charge and FPS made scrolling, animations, and navigation really feel buttery clean.

If we had been large followers of the OnePlus’ 90Hz show, then we have now to be large followers of Google’s 90Hz show, proper? Nicely, not a lot, as Google’s 90Hz show would not run at 90Hz on a regular basis. Like many new options on the Pixel 4, the 90Hz show sounds good on paper, however in actuality, it comes with myriad gotchas.

The Pixel 4's 90Hz display setting only works "for some content."
Enlarge / The Pixel 4’s 90Hz show setting solely works “for some content material.”
Ron Amadeo

Not working in 90Hz on a regular basis is justifiable in some circumstances. If you happen to’re working a full-screen video at 24fps, 30fps, or 60fps, a 90Hz refresh charge will not do something apart from burn battery. Some video games usually are not suitable with 90Hz, so limiting the show there may be applicable, too. The Pixel Four goes a lot additional than this, although, and turns off 90Hz any time you employ Google Maps, Waze, WhatsApp, and Pokémon Go. Pokémon Go is a recreation that’s restricted to 30fps, in order that’s nice. WhatsApp was blacklisted by Google “attributable to poor efficiency below 90hz” in keeping with an Android commit. Google Maps and Waze, Google’s two mapping apps, do not actually have an evidence connected as to why they’re restricted to 60fps on the Pixel 4. We are able to solely assume it is as a result of Waze and Maps are already battery-heavy apps, and Google is nervous in regards to the Pixel 4’s battery life.

The second large refresh charge challenge is that the 90Hz mode is tied to the telephone’s… brightness? Shortly after the telephone hit the market, customers found that, relying on the ambient gentle, the Pixel Four would run in 90Hz mode when above 75% brightness and drop to 60Hz when under 75%. Google PR responded to this discovery, saying the conduct was “preserving battery when larger refresh charges usually are not important.” XDA did some digging and discovered the Android supply commit for this conduct, which explains that “Attributable to [a] {hardware} limitation, glints are seen when switching between 60 and 90Hz at low show and ambient brightness.” Apparently any time you are at midnight, switching from 60 to 90Hz mode can be noticeable, so Google turns off 90Hz mode fully.

Dig into the developer options and you can force 90Hz to be on all the time, just like a real flagship.
Enlarge / Dig into the developer choices and you’ll drive 90Hz to be on on a regular basis, similar to an actual flagship.
Ron Amadeo

You’ll be able to choose out of Google’s 90Hz shenanigans by digging into the hidden-by-default developer settings, which you’ll entry after coming into Android’s model of the Konami code (go to Settings -> About Cellphone and faucet on “construct quantity” seven occasions). In right here, you will discover an choice to “Pressure 90Hz refresh charge” on a regular basis, which then makes the Pixel Four work like each different 90Hz telephone.

With this developer checkbox on, the Pixel Four matches the buttery clean efficiency we have seen from different 90Hz telephones: the animations, scrolling, and transitions are all quicker and smoother feeling. With this checkbox off, eh, it is a crap shoot. The Pixel 4’s brightness and ambient gentle necessities for the 90Hz mode are very excessive, and this appears to require brilliant overhead gentle. Simply retaining the show on and wandering round my home within the daytime is sufficient to have it ping-pong between 60 and 90Hz. The very brightly lit lavatory with the overhead lights? That is ok for 90Hz. The reasonably lit bed room with the lamp within the nook and lightweight coming by means of the window? That is going to drop to 60Hz. Even simply one thing like my head casting a shadow over the sunshine sensor from an overhead gentle is sufficient to have it drop to 60Hz.

You know the way auto brightness is completely loopy and unreliable? Now think about that know-how getting used to regulate the refresh charge of your machine. It’s simply in all places based mostly on the tiniest gentle fluctuations. You will not essentially discover each drop from 90Hz to 60Hz, however the finish result’s that it occurs so incessantly that the Pixel Four would not really feel as quick or fluid as different 90Hz telephones within the default mode. It truly is detrimental to the expertise. It is nice you could flip all these half-measures off, however the overwhelming message from Google is that its 90Hz telephone would not have a sufficiently big battery to help 90Hz mode on a regular basis.

Google issued a patch in November that made the 90Hz mode work in barely brighter situations, however the finish outcome has not modified a lot: the Pixel Four runs in 60Hz mode more often than not.

The show on the Pixel Four XL appears to be like nice in indoor lighting, nevertheless it’s not very brilliant, and also you may need points in daylight. There’s truly a hidden high-brightness mode that was just lately found by XDA. The show has a daylight mode, however Google selected to not expose it to customers. I’d guess it’s because it could use a ton of the machine’s restricted battery.

This yr the Pixel Four helps “Ambient EQ,” a show white stability adjustment that adjustments based mostly on the encircling gentle. It is mainly the Google model of Apple’s True Tone. Ambient EQ beforehand appeared on the Google House Hub, which got here with a particular {hardware} shade sensor and aggressive computerized brightness and white stability controls. I used to be a giant fan of the House Hub implementation, which was so aggressive that it allowed the show to mix into the surroundings, fully eradicating the obtrusive, blasting gentle that usually comes out of a show panel. The Pixel Four would not have the particular shade sensor and solely calmly tweaks the show based mostly on the encircling gentle. It is sufficiently subtle that it would not make an enormous distinction, and I may take it or go away it. I am nonetheless very curious about seeing what a House Hub-style implementation would appear like on a smartphone, although.



About Ron Amadeo

Check Also

TicWatch Pro 4G/LTE Review: Hands-on

Mobvoi’s TicWatch Professional is again and this time boasts mobile connectivity. Does this newfound freedom …

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Advertisements